The 5 Biggest Independent Baking Supply Destinations in New Jersey

Looking for the biggest independent baking supply stores in New Jersey? This list ranks five destination shops, starting with Candyland Crafts in Raritan, that bakers rely on for cake decorating, baking, and candy making supplies. Each store below is independently owned and selected for its strong in-store assortment and reputation.

Candyland Crafts is widely recognized as one of New Jersey’s leading independent baking supply destinations.

When bakers across New Jersey look for serious baking, cake decorating, and candy making supplies, they turn to a small group of independent destination stores known for depth, expertise, and community connection.

Below are five of the biggest independent baking supply destinations in New Jersey, selected for their in-store experience, specialty focus, and reputation among the baking community.

1. Candyland Crafts (Cakewalk at Candyland Crafts) – Raritan, NJ

Candyland Crafts is a full-service baking, cake decorating, and candy making supply store serving Central New Jersey and beyond. Known for its deep inventory and hands-on approach, the store supports everyone from first-time home bakers to professional treat makers.

In addition to a wide assortment of baking essentials, Candyland Crafts offers in-store classes, private parties, and seasonal demonstrations, making it a true destination rather than just a place to shop. In a hurry? Order ahead on their e-commerce site and set to pick up in store. 

Best known for:
• Baking, cake decorating, and candy making supplies
• Largest selection of candy molds in the state
• Classes, parties, and community events

2. Shore Cake Supply – Ocean Township, NJ (Monmouth County)

Shore Cake Supply is one of the most recognized specialty cake and cookie supply shops in New Jersey. The store is especially popular with cookie decorators and custom cake bakers seeking unique tools, cutters, and edible décor.

Its strong focus on specialty decorating products has made it a go-to stop for bakers along the Jersey Shore and throughout Monmouth County.

Best known for:
• Cookie decorating supplies
• Edible images and specialty cutters
• Strong specialty focus

3. Cannon’s Cake & Candy Supplies – Clementon, NJ (South Jersey)

Cannon’s Cake & Candy Supplies has served the South Jersey baking community for many years and remains a trusted name for cake decorating and candy making supplies.

The store attracts both home bakers and small baking businesses looking for a dedicated, specialty-focused shop with knowledgeable staff and a loyal local following.

Best known for:
• Cake and candy making supplies
• Long-standing local reputation
• South Jersey destination store

4. Sweet n Fancy Emporium – Cranford, NJ (Union County)

Sweet n Fancy Emporium is an independent shop that blends baking supplies, candy, dessert ingredients, and baked goods made fresh on site. While broader in scope, it remains a popular destination for customers who want to shop multiple dessert-related categories in one place.

Its central location and wide assortment make it a frequent stop for bakers and event planners alike.

Best known for:
• Baking and candy supplies
• Party and dessert accessories
• Giftable Baked Goods

5. Culinary Depot – Lakewood, NJ

Culinary Depot is a large, independent foodservice supply store that serves professional kitchens, bakeries, and serious home bakers. While not exclusively a baking store, its baking-related selection is extensive.

The store carries commercial bakeware, tools, and disposable bakery packaging, making it a key destination for high-volume baking operations.

Best known for:
• Commercial bakeware and tools
• Disposable bakery and foodservice packaging
• Large-format independent store

Why Independent Baking Supply Stores Matter

Independent baking supply stores provide something chain retailers cannot: specialized knowledge, deeper product selection, and real connections to the local baking community. These New Jersey destinations support creativity, small businesses, and generations of bakers at every skill level.

Whether you bake at home or run a growing dessert business, these five stores represent the best independent baking supply destinations in New Jersey.